The Top Ten Job Posting Warning Signs

Job listings can reveal subtle signs of trouble ahead. Here are ten job posting red flags to watch out for.
10 Job Posting Red Flags To Watch For

A job posting often contains subtle hints that can point to potential issues. When companies draft job ads, their intent is to attract top talent. However, sometimes their approach can inadvertently deter highly qualified candidates. For instance, a job posting that employs misleading language or overly lengthy descriptions may have this effect. Recent research conducted by the Paychex team involved surveying job seekers across the United States who searched for employment within the past year. The results shed light on the criteria these individuals use to evaluate job postings and identify potential warning signs.

Let’s look at the top ten job posting red flags identified by respondents and examine how they influence the application process.

No specified salary range

Compensation is a huge consideration for job seekers, particularly in today’s climate. Therefore, it’s unsurprising that the absence of a salary range ranked as the top red flag (65%). Not disclosing compensation early on may signal to applicants that it is too low. Omitting salary and using phrases like “gain experience” can even suggest an expectation of unpaid work.

Low base salary

Following the lack of a specified salary range, listing a low base salary is a significant concern. While a comprehensive benefits package can sometimes compensate for a lower base salary, this may not suffice. If the pay falls significantly below the candidate’s perceived value without additional benefits, it may not be worth pursuing.

Excessive experience requirement

Demanding several years of experience for entry-level positions can be discouraging. This is especially true for recent graduates who are just starting out. They are looking for fair compensation and opportunities to grow.

Pay commensurate with experience

Job postings that utilize the ambiguous phrase “pay commensurate with experience” raise a red flag. It can be seen as outdated and imply that compensation is determined solely by experience, skills, and education, rather than the nature of the work to be undertaken.

Spelling and grammar mistakes

Just as employers scrutinize resumes for spelling and grammar errors, job seekers are similarly deterred by such mistakes in job postings. These errors signify a lack of attention to detail and professionalism and may deter top candidates who recognize their own worth.

Excessive list of qualifications

A lengthy list of qualifications necessary just to get a foot in the door can be a warning sign. It suggests that the company might lack clarity in defining the role or that the position’s scope is too broad, potentially leaving candidates overwhelmed from day one.

Omission of paid time off

Paid time-off benefits have become a crucial factor for top candidates when choosing an employer. Failing to mention this information can be detrimental to a company’s ability to attract the best talent.

Omission of paid sick leave

The absence of paid sick leave can create productivity challenges, particularly in the current environment where the health of employees is of paramount importance. To attract the top candidates, offering paid sick leave is essential.

Mention of weekend work

A job posting that mentions occasional weekend work might be a concern for those who prioritize family commitments. It can indicate a potential misalignment between personal priorities and workplace expectations.

Excessive interview rounds

According to the survey, most respondents deemed anything beyond two interview rounds as excessive. Ideally, an efficient and well-organized hiring process is preferred. Prolonged interview processes may hint at indecisiveness or an overly consensus-driven approach within the hiring team.

Job postings serve as one of your initial interactions with a potential employer. The last thing you want is to accept an offer only to realize that the position is not as expected. By staying alert to these subtle clues, you can better identify the roles that align with your expectations and career goals.

Are you a woman who needs help changing careers? Download my FREE 22-page e-book: How Professional Women Can Master Career Change!

Share this post

Subscribe to
The Corporate Escape Artist Newsletter

for valuable tips and strategies to get you from soul-sucking job to a fulfilling life and career!

* indicates required